We Kid You Not Childfree Forums

Full Version: How to make real soap
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
I did up a document on how to make soap when I taught a class at the Library. I thought I'd post it here so that if anyone ever decides to go ahead with it they will know where to find the info.

It's very easy. Smile

BASIC SOAPMAKING INSTRUCTIONS

A) Locating lye and safety precautions
B) The equipment list
C) The ten-step procedure

A) Locating lye (sodium hydroxide) and safety precautions

The following may frighten you, but thousands of people make soap everyday without mishap.

You may still be able to find 100% lye sold as a drain cleaner. Red Devil was once the best source, but they no longer seem to manufacture this product.

Generally, the best source is through the internet (see handout of internet resources). I find mine regularly on ebay. One problem is that lye is considered hazardous for shipping purposes, but I have not had to pay hazardous rates through ebay.

Apparently the process of making biodiesel fuel also uses lye, so there are more people looking for it, driving the price up.

Most good soap recipes list lye by weight for accuracy. Make sure you get lye in the granular form, which has a different weight than lye in flake form (the form of lye from laboratory chemical suppliers, pool chemical suppliers, etc).

Scales are a necessary part of successful soapmaking and allow you to use any type of lye.

Lye can be nasty if handled improperly. Keep lye tightly capped. Upon opening a container of lye, the lye crystals absorb water from the air, which can weaken the strength of the lye and cause it to form a solid lump.

Lye reacts with some metals: aluminum, zinc, and tin. Safe containers include heatproof stoneware, glass, enamel, stainless steel and plastic.

Lye, lye/water and freshly-made soap can burn and irritate skin. You'll notice itching before burning. Lye/water on skin is first noticed by a slippery feeling. Rinse your hands with vinegar and immediately rinse them with running water.

Since lye can burn skin, you can imagine what it does to eyes! Always wear eye protection! Wear sunglasses if you have to!

Lye can be fatal if swallowed.

Some people are extremely sensitive to fumes that come from the lye/water. Fumes also come from the stirring container. Fumes from small batches (1 pound) usually isn't enough to cause a problem. Be very careful not to breathe in while you are stirring or peering at your lye/water mixture.

Be aware than larger amounts of lye (larger batches of soap) create more fumes. With prolonged contact, fumes can burn the eyes and skin of sensitive people. If you make soap in large amounts and afterward feel as if your face is "sun burned," chances are it was caused by fumes.

Children, pets and feeble-minded people should not be in the soapmaking area or have access to stored soapmaking ingredients, especially lye and essential oil.


B) Equipment you will need

1. One 4-to-6 cup mixing container made of lye-resistant material (I use a plastic juice pitcher with a lid)

2. One pot that holds at least 4 cups (I use a stainless steel pot)

3. Stainess steel, plastic, wooden spoon or a rubber spatula

4. Two thermometers made of glass or stainless steel (candy or meat thermometers)

5. Eye protection (wear sunglasses if you have to!)

6. Rubber gloves (dish gloves)

7. Accurate scale to weight the fats and lye

8. Soap molds (any flexible plastic container works well)

C) The Ten-step Procedure

1) Put on eye protection and rubber gloves.

2) Use a heat-proof container to measure the amount of cold water specified in the recipe. Cold water is important. If you add lye to hot or boiling water, the water could "boil-up" out of the container. Stir the water and slowly add the lye. The water will get hot and turn cloudy. Continue to stir until the lye dissolves. Don't breathe or intentionally smell the fumes coming from the cup because they are quite "chokey." If you wait too long to stir the water, the lye could harden in the bottom of the container. This is not a problem. You can still stir it, but it will be more difficult. Add a glass or stainless steel thermometer to the lye/water and wait until it reaches the temperature specified in the recipe.

3) Heat the fat.
Put the fats in a lye-resistant container and place a glass or stainless steel thermometer into the fats. Be sure the thermometer doesn't touch the bottom of the container and give a false reading. Heat the fats and optional ingredients to the temperature specified in the recipe.

4) When both the fat and the lye/water reach the temperature specified in the recipe, add the lye/water to the fat. It's sometimes a balancing act to get the fat mixture and the lye/water mixture to specific temperatures at the same time. Never place lye/water in a microwave (the cup could break).

I have found that a temperature between 105F-110F seems to work the best. The key is that both solutions are the same temperature.

It takes lye/water longer to cool than it takes fat to heat. When both the lye/water and the fat are within five degrees of the temperatures specified in the recipe, use a pot holder and move the bowl to a sink (to contain splatters). Slowly pour the lye/water into the fats while stirring.

5) Stir the soap until it "traces."
When lye, water and fat first combine, the mixture is thin and watery. Gradually, as the lye and fat react chemically to form soap, the mixture thickens and turns opaque.

"Tracing" is a term to describe the consistency (thickness) of soap when it's ready to pour into molds.

I use a stick blender to completely put the oil mixture into contact with the lye/water mixture.

To test for tracing:

a. Drip some soap onto the surface of the soap in the stirring bowl. It should leave a "trace" or small mound.

b. Draw a line in the soap with a spoon or rubber spatula. If a "trace" of the line remains for a few seconds, the soap has traced.

Tracing is easy to recognize, yet it causes new soapmakers a lot of worry. Relax and know that the soap will trace eventually. Just stir the soap constantly for the first 15 minutes or so, then stir the soap every fifteen minutes until it thickens and traces, no matter how long it takes. If you use a stick blender, you’ll only have to blend for about 2-3 minutes or less.

6) After the soap traces, add up to one tablespoon essential oil (if desired) and stir a few minutes longer to incorporate the oil. Essentials oils are necessary for a pleasant-smelling product.

7) Pour the soap into molds and wait for it to harden. The recipes states this length of time as 'time in mold.' Cover the molds and place them in a warm place where they will not be disturbed. Do not peek at them – each peek will reduce the temperature and you want them to stay warm. I wrap mine in a blanket and put them next to the heating vent.

8) Unmold the soap.
Soap can be still harsh when it's time to remove it from the molds. Put on rubber gloves and press the back of each mold compartment to release the soap. It's a lot like removing ice cubes from a tray. Sometimes the soap doesn't release easily from the mold. To overcome this problem, leave the soap in a freezer for a few hours. Freezing soap causes it to contract slightly, become hard and release from the plastic mold.

9) Wait the time specified in a recipe for the soap to"age" (usually 3 weeks). During the aging time the pH of the soap decreased (the soap becomes mild) and the bars harden. It's a good idea to write the following information on a piece of paper and place it with the soap: the date you made the soap, the date the aging time is over, and recipe.

10) Step 10 is *enjoy your soap!*
As soap ages, a fine, white powder may appear on the surface. This is soda ash (sodium carbonate) formed by a reaction of lye with carbon dioxide in air. This white powder is mostly on the surface exposed to air while the soap was in the molds. Soap that contains wax develops little or no soda ash.

There are three ways to deal with soda ash:

a. Try to prevent it.
Immediately after pouring soap into molds, cover the soap with plastic wrap or waxed paper. Press the wrap or paper onto the surface of the soap to prevent air contact.

b. Cut it away.
Overfill the molds slightly. Later, when the soap hardens, take a knife and cut the soap level with the mold. This also cuts away the soda ash.

c. Wash it away.
Wait until the soap ages and hardens. Wash the powder away by rubbing the soap with your hands under running water or by rubbing the soap over a wet dishcloth. Set the soap aside to dry -- then enjoy your soap!
Wow! Detailed, pretty cool. I think I'll try it out sometime. Thanks!
There has to be an alternative to lye. That just sounds like WAY too much trouble for something so corrosive and freakishly hard to get.
Lye is the traditional way to make "real soap".
Here are some alternatives:

http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&q=lye+...tive&meta=

http://www.frybrid.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3498
Jo - it's really not that bad. I just used super-cautious language - this is a handout I did for the Library class, so I didn't want one of them getting hurt and then saying it was my fault... as long as you use reasonable precautions (I wear my glasses and rubber gloves and take care not to breathe in fumes) it's fine. I find the lye on ebay without too much trouble. Smile I'll post my recipe next.
ONE BASIC STARTER RECIPE

16oz Vegetable Shortening
7oz Olive Oil
7oz White Coconut Oil
1oz Cocoa Butter
4oz Lye
12oz Water*

*Some soapmakers swear by distilled water, but I have never tried it.

Follow basic soapmaking directions. When lye/water and oils mixtures reach 110F, pour lye mixture into oil mixture.

½ tbsp – 1tbsp of borax can be added to whiten.

Add colors and other essential oils if desired as you blend the two mixtures together. If you are using more than ½ ounce of essential oils you may find that you need to slightly increase the amount of lye – by less than one ounce, or slightly decrease the amount of one of the oils – again by less than one ounce.
cassia Wrote:Lye is the traditional way to make "real soap".
Here are some alternatives:

http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&q=lye+...tive&meta=

http://www.frybrid.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3498

Cassia - the first link doesn't give alternatives to using lye - the recipes given still use lye they are just using liquids other than water like goat's milk.

There's no way to make real soap w/o lye unless you do "gylcerin melt and pour soaps" and that just means that some other person already did the lye process before you - all you are doing is melting and pouring the end product, so to speak.
Can I ask you something?

Why would we rub something against our skin that is so corrosive as to require goggles to use? That kind of scares me! Meanwhile I know I must have been using it my whole life, but still!!! LOL

After having just dropped altogether too much money on a box of LUSH products, this soapmaking actually does sound like fun! If not for the goggles, children/pets/feeble parts. LOL

PrairieGirl

My understanding is that the lye is required to make a chemical reaction, and that it's burned off in the process. So you don't rub your skin with lye.

Still, it IS kinda hinky, isn't it!!!
Seriously, when I walked into LUSH in Boston I nearly died laughing. All that stuff in that store I can make at home for say 10% of the price and with a lot more personal satisfaction. It was crazy in there! And the way they sell it is even more hilarious - it's in these huge slabs - not even packaged. So you actually pay MORE for them saving $ on packaging. They have a marketing genius working there.

Their store is in one of the most expensive real estate areas in Boston. Their mark-up has got to be astronomical.

Jo if you want to swing by on your trip I'll show you how incredibly easy it is to make soap.

Up until about 100 years ago soap making was a pretty common thing to do for many people. And they didn't have the sophisticated lye sources we do. They had to use the ash from their woodstoves and soak it in water to make the lye solution. Imagine that!
Shades of "Granny Clampett" You mean to tell me people today still
MAKE soap???????
LOL
OK whatever floats your boat... & More power to you.
I prefer to buy me a bar of unscented Ivory soap.
(I was born with sensitive skin) then to go to all that hard work in making home made soap.

But to each their ownBalloon & Goodluck

FuzzBunny

I've got a couple of cousins who make soaps to sell. They have some pretty nifty scents but they use natural ingredients, so it's not as drying or irritating as commercial soaps.
I make soap also!!

Soap making is easy once you get the hang of it. If anyone has any questions, I can provide guidance too.

Even though lye is a caustic substance, it is needed to make real soap. Soap making is actually a chemical reaction. When you mix lye with fat and oils (like olive oil), the lye bonds with the oils and changes its chemical makeup, turning it into soap.

Even though soap is made with lye, finished soap, does NOT contain ANY lye! And the process creates a very MILD, yummy soap that's good for you skin.

It's even good for dry or sensitive skin.

It's also not hard to find if you know where to look! You can find it at Lowes! It's in the drain cleaner aisle. It's called Roebic Crystal Drain Opener.

Most products in the store that are marketed as soap are actually not true soap. They are synthetic detergents. Some products, like Dove, contain both synthetic detergents and also true soap. One of the reasons that the cheap bars of "soap" at the store are so drying to the skin is because during the process, they take out the glycerin and resell it in other products. Glycerin is one of the key ingredients of true soap that make it so nice on the skin. Glycerin is one of the by products of the soap making process.
Cool, jmk!! Thank you so much for the info about the lye source. I had no idea that there was another brand other than Red Devil out there! This is terrific.

You're dead on about glycerin. That's what makes homemade soaps so nice! The process is fun, too, for me, anyway.

I taught a class at the library on it to about a dozen people. It was fun. I know I could probably buy soap cheaper in the store, but I enjoy knowing it's my own. Smile

How long have you been doing it and what got you started?
I actually haven't been doing it very long. Only about 4 months. But I've been researching it so much and reading as much as I can that I feel like I've been making it forever! I've always been a very crafty person and if I'm not creating something, I feel like I'll go insane with boredom. A friend of mine and I both had wanted to make soap for a while now, so we did it together.

I guess what got me started is I'm started to try and lead a more self-sufficient lifestyle. And a "greener" lifestyle. I started using canvas bags when I do shopping. I've been keeping chickens for a couple years. I want to start composting and possibly start a worm bin. So soap making was a natural step.

Plus, it's just SUPER FUN!!! I'm working on creating a master batch recipe right now that I can use variations of to create other soaps. I've made a couple batches so far, one was very sucessful batch of soap so far. It's a Jasmine soap made with shea butter, jojoba oil and jasmine tea. I even put tea leaves in it for some mild scrubbiness.

I've also helped my friend make several other batches that she is working on. So far I've only done cold process, but I recently bought a book about liquid soap using potassium hydroxide (pot ash) instead of sodium hydroxide (lye). You also use the hot process for those. I think I'm going to try those next.
CNK-
I wanted to update you on a resource for Lye if you need it. My friend and I have officially started a soap business and we are going to try to get into a couple craft fairs this year. But the Drain cleaner from Lowes that I mentioned above is no longer available. But I found another source for both Lye and potash (for liquid soap) if you need it.

http://www.lyedepot.com/

They are relatively cheap and right now they are doing a sale. They are giving away and extra 2lb bottle of lye with most purchases. I just bought some potash from them and the transaction was quick and the shipping was fast. I recommend them.
Thanks, jmk! This is good news. It's depressing how hard it's gotten to find lye. I haven't made soap in a while - time to drag out the supplies.
Reference URL's