September 10, 2009
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
SYDNEY–World 800-metre champion Caster Semenya of South Africa has male and female sexual organs, the Sydney Morning Herald reported Friday, posing an ethical and political quandary for world track and field's ruling body.
The Herald said extensive physical examinations of the 18-year-old runner ordered by the IAAF have shown she is technically a hermaphrodite.
Medical reports indicate she has no ovaries, but rather has internal male testes, which are producing large amounts of testosterone.
The newspaper said the IAAF was trying to contact the athlete to inform her of the results.
After dominating her race at the world championships in Berlin last month, Semenya was given blood and chromosome tests as well as a gynecological examination.
"This is a medical issue and not a doping issue where she was deliberately cheating," IAAF spokesman Nick Davies was quoted as saying by the newspaper.
"These tests do not suggest any suspicion of deliberate misconduct but seek to assess the possibility of a potential medical condition which would give Semenya an unfair advantage over her competitors. There is no automatic disqualification of results in a case like this."
The IAAF has said Semenya would probably keep her medal because the case was not related to a drug matter. But the Herald said an alternative possibility was to award a second gold to the runner-up, Janeth Jepkosgei from Kenya.
Wow, that's a toughie. Here's what I think:
1 -- I'm furious that the press was notified before the patient, a violation of her medical privacy.
2 -- The reason why women run differently from men is because of the structure of their hips. Women run inefficiently, and require more energy to accomplish the same power and speed as a man. It's not about either testosterone or estrogen. If her hips are built like a woman's, she should compete as a woman. If her hips are built like a man's, she should compete as a man.
Let her keep her spoils so far, because she deserves them.
Check her testosterone levels. If they are unusually high then she can't compete as a woman. I think that there are tests for this normally, or perhaps they don't test reguarly but I'm almost positive that there are guidelines in place.
(09-11-2009 05:26 PM)Ziggy Wrote: [ -> ]Let her keep her spoils so far, because she deserves them.
Check her testosterone levels. If they are unusually high then she can't compete as a woman. I think that there are tests for this normally, or perhaps they don't test reguarly but I'm almost positive that there are guidelines in place.
Let me jump on this bandwagon. Otherwise we have shades of all those awful East German incidents. She wasn't cheating; she didn't know. Now that we know, I guess the answer is regular testing.
I thought the same thing-the East German incidents-when I first read the story. Actually, I'm thinking her condition isn't really that rare. When you look at competitors in most international events, there seem to be quite a few of female athletes from all over who look half man/half woman-not just East Germans. There have been and are a few female pro tennis players that come to mind also. The question is how many took male hormones or whatever to get those features and how many were born that way. I guess there will be a new set of testing done at international events.
Dog Holliday is right - her condition is not rare. Contrary to how our society likes to consider it, gender is a continuum. There are people who fall throughout the spectrum. There are children born who do not fall into either category strictly - male or female - parents generally put them through surgery to "correct" the "problem". Too bad the society can't just accept that there's more than just male/female...
As to this question - it's really hard. Testing seems the only way.
We've understood for years that sexuality is a continuum. Now we are learning that gender is, too. One thing everyone can take from this is that gender is mostly a social construct. Just be yourself. Be a human. Treat everyone around you as a human. Nothing else is all that big a deal.
I completely agree with eslbee.
Old thinking was to pigeon-hole gender.
Why not expand our thinking when challenged by new information and possibilities?
I found this article an interesting take on it:
The salacious sports media and the puritanical zealots that run international track and field have joined forces to hit a new low. Someone in the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) leaked to the press that Caster Semenya, the 18-year-old 800-meter track champion from South Africa, is, in the words of Oren Yaniv in the New York Daily News, both "a woman... and a man!"
Dave Zirin: The ongoing obsession in the West over Caster Semenya's gender only serves to highlight the understanding and acceptance shown her in South Africa.
Stop the Sex Scare in Sports
Dave Zirin & Sherry Wolf: The salacious sports media and the puritanical zealots that run international track and field have joined forces to hit a new low.
*
Sex-Testing Victim Semenya Stands Tall
Sports
Dave Zirin: The ongoing obsession in the West over Caster Semenya's gender only serves to highlight the understanding and acceptance shown her in South Africa.
After being subjected to a battery of "gender tests," which included invasive exams by a gynecologist, an endocrinologist and a psychologist, Semenya's private business is now presented for public consumption.
If the leaks are to be regarded as true, they show that Caster Semenya has internal testes and no womb or ovaries. She is possibly one of the millions of people in the world (one of 1,666 births in the United States alone) who are classified as "intersex."
Or she may have Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS), which affects two to five out of every 100,000 births. The different biological gender classifications are complex, ever changing and, ideally, private. But to the drooling press, it's vulture time.
As Yaniv wrote, "The tests, ordered...after Semenya's 800-meter victory in the World Championships, determined she's a hermaphrodite--having both male and female organs." Now the story has gone international, and Caster Semenya has gone into hiding.
Forget for a moment that the term "hermaphrodite" is as outdated and offensive as "mulatto." Forget that these test results were leaked first to the Australian press, which also referred to Semenya as a hermaphrodite. Forget that Australia was the country that brought these accusations against Semenya in the first place.
Besides being a cruel and idiotic practice, sex testing doesn't account for the idea that gender is at least in part socially constructed and far more fluid than the iron categories of male and female. An 18-year-old woman is being torn apart in the press for doing nothing but winning a race. If it is the goal of the media and IAAF to destroy the life of a young, talented female athlete by outing her as potentially intersex then they are not simply pitiless; they are socially repugnant.
From the notion that women are somehow weaker and slower than men, to the not-so-subtle racism of Western standards of appearance, and on to their profound ignorance about the fluidity of sex and gender, these institutions are threatening to catapult women in sports back into the Dark Ages. We can't let them.
Being a woman--or a man--is not reducible to internal organs or chromosomes. Social, historical, political and economic forces shape who we are and how we perceive our gender identities, in addition to our biology.
We should be enraged by the indifference and crass opportunism at "sexy" headlines. We must demand an end to gender testing in sports as an ill-conceived endeavor that only results in tormenting its subjects and projecting garbage ideas about what men and women really are.
And after all the horror, outrage and ogling from the Daily News and its media brethren, Semenya's condition may very well be allowable under IAAF policy.
As Science of Sport reported, "While it may be suggested that being an intersex individual, or someone who is 'not entirely female,' is grounds for disqualification, it is not. In Atlanta in 1996, eight women 'failed' the sex verification test because they had a Y-chromosome (strictly speaking, they had the SRY gene or the Y-chromosome). All eight were allowed to compete."
Since 2005 eight athletes that we know about have been investigated for "sexuality issues." Of the eight, according to the IAAF secretary general, only four "were asked to stop their career."
Dr. Myron Genel, a professor emeritus of pediatrics at Yale University who was part of a special panel of experts the IAAF convened, said, "She's born a female, raised as a female through puberty. Whatever is found, with the exception of deliberate substance abuse, she's going to have to be allowed to compete as a female."
If Semenya's biology is not "normal," it's worth asking, what world-class athlete does have a normal body?
No one brands Shaquille O'Neal abnormal because he is seven feet tall. Michael Phelps, as was remarked by breathless Olympics commentators, has unusually large and flat feet that act like flippers in a pool. Usain Bolt has a stride that allows him to cover an insane amount of ground in only a few steps.
As Tommy Craggs of Deadspin writes, "Great athletes tend not to come from the vast middle of human life. They're all freaks in one way or another.... But Semenya has nevertheless been portrayed as some lone oddity on the margins, like some Elephant Man of sports, with everyone obsessing like Victorian scientists over the presence of a couple internal testicles. It's funny: People seem to think her very weirdness is grounds enough for stripping her of her medal and drumming her out of track. But this is sports. Her weirdness is perfectly normal."
It's the "her" part that gets Semenya in trouble. Exceptional male athletes are treated like kings, not sideshow freaks. But for women to join them on the royal dais, you must appear as if you can step seamlessly from the court or track and into the pages of soft-core porn. Freaks need not apply.
There are real fears, expressed by Semenya's family, for her mental health in the wake of this maelstrom. We should stand without question in solidarity with Caster Semenya and express nothing but contempt for those who would get off, financially or otherwise, on seeing her destroyed.
EXCELLENT article - thank you for posting. This is great:
Quote:As Tommy Craggs of Deadspin writes, "Great athletes tend not to come from the vast middle of human life. They're all freaks in one way or another.... But Semenya has nevertheless been portrayed as some lone oddity on the margins, like some Elephant Man of sports, with everyone obsessing like Victorian scientists over the presence of a couple internal testicles. It's funny: People seem to think her very weirdness is grounds enough for stripping her of her medal and drumming her out of track. But this is sports. Her weirdness is perfectly normal."
It's the "her" part that gets Semenya in trouble. Exceptional male athletes are treated like kings, not sideshow freaks. But for women to join them on the royal dais, you must appear as if you can step seamlessly from the court or track and into the pages of soft-core porn. Freaks need not apply.
This is not a controversy. It is a nontroversy. There are plenty of hermaphrodites in the world, but we keep hiding the issue because it makes the omnipresent sexism in our society untenable. There is no "ethical and political quandary" here because it's not an ethical or a political issue. It is only an issue at all because we persist in segregating and persecuting people on the basis of inborn traits.